13 Comments
User's avatar
Walter Kemp Bruce's avatar

They should make a film about the Jacobite rebellion and bonnie Prince Charlie. It’s a great, sad story.

Jackie Kemp's avatar

Thanks. Well Outlander is basically about the Jacobites - but I wouid like to see a film of Waverley

Neil MacArthur's avatar

Inverness has always been a bland city with nothing rewarding for a tourist that seeks historical culture. The new 'castle' will do nothing to change this.

Jackie Kemp's avatar

Certainly the 1970s were not kind to it. There are some hideous buildings. We think the Mercure Hotel is the best place to stay - because it’s the only place where you can’t see the Mercure Hotel

Ann Rayner's avatar

People reading this should be aware that the decades folloeing Scotland continued to be brutal as we were effectively an occupied country with British army garrisons and an occupying army of redcoats ensuring (mainly Highlanders) kept to the rules forbidding kilts, Gaelic and bearing arms with extreme force.

I can testify to this having been part of a small group inspired by historian Suart McHardy who discovered the 'Cantonment Documents' in the library of Edinburgh Castle's military museum and transcribed them from photocopies of the English officers reports. These were then passed on to Murray Pittock, who included the information in a book he was writing around then ut also distributed, along with map showing the coverage, to a great many schools and museums in Scotland. It is very likely that Inverness museum will have copies.

Jackie Kemp's avatar

Thank you for that, what was the name of the book? Was it The Myth of the Jacobite Clans (1995)

Ann Rayner's avatar

Possibly, but I don't think I ever knew the title of the book that included our findings.

Like many historians, Murray Pittock often worked on more than one book at a time, depending on the information/ research which became available.

HaveFunMakeMoneyLive Better's avatar

In the meantime read SG MacLean’s “The Bookseller of Inverness”. It is a fantastic read and incredibly detailed and historically accurate.

A fabulous writer and this stand alone is one of her best.

Jackie Kemp's avatar

I actually just got the audiobook and I am enjoying it - thanks

HaveFunMakeMoneyLive Better's avatar

Also The Redemption of Alexander Seaton is incredible

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 5
Comment deleted
Jackie Kemp's avatar

I totally agree - there is a sense that telling Scots about our own history would be like Serbians creating some kind of ancient national blood and soil narrative or something. It is the same in the NMS which is "object-led" not story led

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 5
Comment deleted
Jackie Kemp's avatar

Yes the timidity is very much there

Duncan Clark's avatar

They took away the fish, and look what happened.